Find the most up-to-date version of ISO at Engineering ISOpdf – Download as PDF File .pdf) or read online. ASTM A method E is sometimes called the Strauss test, and is the same as ISO method A, except for the duration. As 15 hours is a difficult test period .
|Published (Last):||12 September 2007|
|PDF File Size:||8.91 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||15.5 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
There are a number of recognised tests when it comes to the intergranular corrosion testing of corrosion resistant alloys CRA.
This document describes all three of these tests for four common standards, and describes the differences. Just remember that these tests were devised for specific groups of alloys and should not be applied to all CRAs! This document also points out which alloys the tests are intended for, and recommends the most appropriate test when none is specified. These tests were introduced when the carbon content in CRAs typically hit 0. This means that carbide formation during welding is highly unlikely, and modern CRAs should easily pass one of these tests.
Table 1 below shows the various methods for four common standards: The latter is a German test, but it is often called up in European projects.
The exception to this is ASTM G28 method A, where rates for the onset of intergranular corrosion are described in reference 1. For many alloys, the onset is at 0.
Some suggested criteria for the listed alloys are shown in Table 2, below. Good material should have a corrosion rate substantially less than the threshold value. For alloys not listed in this standard, it will be necessary to carry out some tests on material in various conditions to determine the threshold.
Where a bend test is required, the sample must be bent over a mandrel of a diameter related to the specimen diameter, without any cracking, as determined by inspection under a low power microscope and a microsection in any suspicious areas.
The specifications for bend testing are shown in Table 4. All bend tests require a tensile test machine or similar, with suitable grips and sufficient strength to bend the strongest alloy. Samples may be rectangular or cylindrical to suit the test vessel, but where a bend test is isl, it is suggested that the sample be a minimum of mm long.
The most convenient size is often a cylinder 10mm diameter by mm long, but other dimensions are possible to suit particular product forms. Some standards require the test sample to be aged prior to testing, to simulate the precipitation that might occur during welding. It does not say what to do about duplex or super austenitic alloys. ASTM G28 does not require samples to be heat treated. ISO is specifically for duplex and all austenitic stainless steels, and recommends ageing at two different temperatures:.
Both of these tests should be followed by water quenching. Alternatively, a welded test-piece in the as-welded condition may be tested. SEP does not require ageing, although it might be required in a specification calling up this standard. The test methods in Table 1 were designed with specific alloys in mind, but the proliferation of new CRAs has meant that the selection of a suitable test method is difficult.
ASTM A was designed for austenitic stainless steels, specifically the series alloys.
The Jso test method C is only for molybdenum-free grades, such as L, as alloys with molybdenum show high rates of attack in this test. Hence, it is normally only used for stainless steels intended for nuclear service, or another application involving nitric acid.
Intergranular Corrosion Tests for CRAs
It has been used for the duplex stainless steel UNS Swhich has been used for nitric acid cooler tubes. Methods B and E are suggested for all grades of series austenitic alloys, while method F is 3561-2 for cast type alloys. ASTM G28 was designed for nickel-based alloys, and a list of applicable alloys for methods A and B is in the standard. For an alloy that is not listed, look for an alloy with a similar composition to a listed alloy to determine the most suitable test.
ISO is the most rigorous in terms of defining test methods, and says which alloys should use which test methods as follows:.
It can be seen that some alloys fall into two categories, and no guidelines are given for selecting the most appropriate. Where a standard is included in a purchase specification, this must be followed, although it is advised that unsuitable tests, such as the Huey test for duplex and super austenitic stainless steels, are queried. More suitable alternatives are offered in Table 5, below. Where no specific test is specified, Table 5 suggests the most appropriate alongside a second choice, if the first is declined.
When a test has been selected, follow the detailed directions in 36651-2 standard for making up the test solution, the preparation of test samples and the finish to be used.
There are other requirements in these standards over details that are not discussed in this document, and these should be followed, such as conducting bend iao.
R Baboian, Corrosion Tests and Standards: Bend test criteria for several standards. Suggested test methods for different corrosion resistant alloys. Contact us by Phone or Email to find out how we can help your industry. Why were these tests designed?
The Tests Table 1 below shows the various methods for four common standards: ASTM G28 lists alloys and specifies the test exposure for each. This test should be avoided for most CRAs, except in the circumstances described below, in section 4.
As 15 hours is a difficult test period in practice, and is only a minimum, conducting the test for 20 hours overnight means that the two tests are equivalent.
None of these are identical and cross substitution of results is not possible. ASTM G28 method B is a more aggressive test than method A and is intended for more corrosion resistant alloys, as listed in the document. SEP method 3 is a special environment only suitable for the Ni-Mo alloys, as described below, in section 4. Test Samples Samples may be rectangular or cylindrical to suit the test vessel, but where a bend test is required, it is suggested that the sample be a minimum of mm long.
ISO is specifically for duplex and all austenitic stainless steels, and recommends ageing at two different temperatures: Selection of a Test Method The test methods in Table 1 were designed with specific alloys in mind, but the proliferation of new CRAs has meant that the selection of a suitable test method is difficult.
ISO is the most rigorous in terms of defining test methods, and says which alloys should use which test methods as follows: SEP also gives guidance on which of its methods apply to which alloys: Conducting the Tests When a test has been selected, follow the detailed directions in that standard for making up the test solution, the preparation of test samples and the finish to be used.